[isf-wifidog] Can someone test qos-scripts and WiFiDog together?

[Andrew Hodel]

Unlikely that this combination will ever work.

qos-scripts is nothing more then iptables/tc.  Wifidog at the iptables
level would need quite a bit of remodeling to work with qos-scripts
iptables structure.

If you are looking for some sort of QOS, just build your own tc
scripts and leave iptables completely out.  It's not all that
complicated, and you can take a look at the old wondershaper scripts
to get started.



Regards,
Andrew Hodel


On Fri, Apr 24, 2009 at 2:05 PM,  <aaronz at pls-net.org> wrote:
> Does someone have a little time to try replicating this problem (preferably on a WRT54GL) and make certain I am not crazy here?
>
> I can get this error from a vanilla OpenWRT install (openwrt-brcm-2.4-squashfs) on a WRT54GL V1.1 after installing QOS-Scripts and WiFiDog.
>
> Config directions:
> 1. Install OpenWrt 8.09 (http://downloads.openwrt.org/kamikaze/8.09/brcm-2.4/openwrt-brcm-2.4-squashfs.trx is what I am using)
> 1. Install and configure QOS:
>        1. Install QOS (and dependent packages) with opkg
>        2. Replace the #INTERFACES section of the qos config file with this one (I have not made any other changes to the file):
> #########Begin QOS config##############
> #File Location: /etc/config/qos
> # INTERFACES:
> config interface wan
>        option classgroup  "Default"
>        option enabled      1
>                option overhead     1
>               option upload       250
>        option download     2500
> #########End QOS config###############
>
>
> 2. Install and configure WiFiDog:
>        1. Install WiFiDog (and dependent packages) with opkg
>        2. Replace the WiFiDog configuration file with the following file (after adding your auth server information, mine works when qos isn't running, so I don't think that it is the issue):
>
> #########Begin WiFiDog config###############
> # File Location: /etc/wifidog.conf
> # WiFiDog Configuration file
>
> GatewayID LIBRARY0
>
> #ExternalInterface br-wan
> #if I try to set ExternalInterface variable in this file I get an invalid interface error on startup, but when
> #WiFiDog starts (and automatically detects the interfaces) it uses br-wan.
>
> GatewayInterface br-lan
>
> #Insert your auth server info here, ours isn't available from the internet (and it works when QOS is off, so I don't think it could be the problem)
> AuthServer {
>     Hostname #Insert your auth server info here
>     HTTPPort 80
>     Path #Insert your auth server info here
> }
>
> CheckInterval 60
>
> ClientTimeout 5
>
> FirewallRuleSet global {
>
> }
>
> FirewallRuleSet validating-users {
>    FirewallRule block tcp port 25
>    FirewallRule allow to 0.0.0.0/0
> }
>
>
> FirewallRuleSet known-users {
>    FirewallRule allow to 0.0.0.0/0
> }
>
> FirewallRuleSet unknown-users {
>    FirewallRule allow udp port 53
>    FirewallRule allow tcp port 53
>    FirewallRule allow udp port 67
>    FirewallRule allow tcp port 67
> }
>
> FirewallRuleSet locked-users {
>    FirewallRule block to 0.0.0.0/0
> }
> #########End WiFiDog config###############
>
>
> 3. Start qos (/etc/init.d/qos enable) and WiFiDog (/etc/init.d/wifidog enable) then reboot the box
>
> 4. Can you authenticate and then browse the internet?
>
> If someone could do this I would appreciate it very much.
>
> Thanks
>
> Aaron Z
> Jr. Systems Administrator
>
> Pioneer Library System
> 2557 State Rt. 21
> Canandaigua, New York  14424
> Phone: (585) 394-8260
> Fax: (585) 394-1935
>
>> I am trying to use QOS Scripts and WiFiDog together on a WRT54GL V1.1,
>> I am using OpenWRT 8.09 and WiFiDog 1.1.5-2, the problem is that
>> whenever I enable QOS for the WAN port WiFiDog stops allowing users
>> online after authenticating (they get the message saying that they are
>> authenticated, but they cant go anywhere after that). Have these
>> packages been tested together? If so, are there any known issues?
> _______________________________________________
> WiFiDog mailing list
> WiFiDog at listes.ilesansfil.org
> http://listes.ilesansfil.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/wifidog
>